Understanding product liability, autonomous driving systems, insurance disputes, and the legal risks of electric vehicles under Texas law
Electric vehicles are becoming an increasingly familiar sight on Texas roads. With sophisticated battery systems, advanced computer technology, and features that can assist with steering, braking, and acceleration, modern vehicles are fundamentally different from the automobiles most Americans grew up driving.
But technological advancement creates new legal questions.
What happens when an electric vehicle's battery catches fire? Who is responsible when a vehicle operating with automated driving assistance strikes a pedestrian? Can a manufacturer be sued when software makes a dangerous decision? And does a driver remain responsible for an accident when the vehicle was supposedly driving itself?
These questions involve an evolving intersection of Texas negligence law, product liability, federal motor vehicle safety regulation, and insurance coverage.
Understanding the distinction between an ordinary automobile accident and an accident involving potentially defective technology can make a substantial difference in determining liability.
1. Electric Vehicles Introduce Different Types of Risks
Electric vehicles are not necessarily more dangerous than gasoline-powered automobiles. Indeed, some electric vehicles incorporate sophisticated collision-avoidance systems and other safety features.
However, they introduce risks that differ from those associated with conventional vehicles.
Among the most significant are:
These risks do not automatically establish legal liability. An accident or malfunction must be examined to determine whether negligence, a product defect, or another legally recognized basis for recovery exists.
2. Battery Fires and Thermal Runaway: What Makes Electric Vehicles Different?
One of the most distinctive hazards associated with electric vehicles involves the high-voltage battery pack.
Many electric vehicles use lithium-ion batteries containing large quantities of stored energy.
When certain battery cells are damaged, overheated, improperly manufactured, or otherwise compromised, they may experience a process known as thermal runaway.
Thermal runaway occurs when heat-generating reactions inside a battery cell become self-sustaining. Under some circumstances, heat can propagate to neighboring cells, producing a larger fire.
These events can be difficult to control and may involve toxic or flammable gases, extreme temperatures, and the possibility of reignition.
Potential contributing factors include:
Importantly, the mere occurrence of a battery fire does not prove that a vehicle was defective.
A battery that ignites following an extremely severe collision may present a different legal question from one that ignites while an undamaged vehicle is parked in a residential garage.
The circumstances surrounding the failure matter enormously.
3. Can You Sue an Electric Vehicle Manufacturer for a Battery Fire?
Under Texas law, a manufacturer or other potentially responsible party may face liability when a defective product causes injury or property damage.
Texas product liability law recognizes several theories, including manufacturing defects, design defects, and inadequate warnings or instructions.
Manufacturing defects
A manufacturing defect generally involves a product that departs from its intended design or specifications.
For example, a battery cell containing a manufacturing irregularity might fail even though the broader battery design was reasonably safe.
A plaintiff would ordinarily need evidence establishing the defect and connecting it to the injury.
Design defects
A design defect involves a claim that the product's design creates an unreasonable danger.
Under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 82.005, a claimant asserting a design-defect claim generally must establish that a safer alternative design existed and that the defect was a producing cause of the injury or damage.
A safer alternative design must satisfy statutory requirements concerning feasibility, risk reduction, and the product's utility.
A plaintiff cannot simply argue that the manufacturer should have built a perfectly safe battery.
The legal inquiry is considerably more demanding.
Failure to warn
A manufacturer may also face allegations that it failed to provide adequate warnings or instructions concerning reasonably foreseeable dangers.
For example, litigation might examine whether a manufacturer adequately disclosed known risks associated with battery damage, charging, flooding, or other operating conditions.
Whether a warning was legally inadequate depends on the specific facts, applicable law, and relationship between the alleged omission and the injury.
4. Who Pays When an Electric Vehicle Catches Fire in a Garage?
Consider a hypothetical Texas homeowner who parks an electric vehicle in an attached garage.
Several hours later, the vehicle catches fire. The flames spread to the house, causing substantial structural damage.
The homeowner may face hundreds of thousands of dollars in losses.
Who is responsible?
The answer depends on the cause of the fire.
If investigators determine that a defective battery component caused the fire, a product liability claim against the manufacturer or another responsible party may be possible.
If an improperly installed charging circuit caused the fire, the electrical contractor or equipment manufacturer might instead face scrutiny.
If the fire resulted from improper repairs, a repair facility could potentially bear responsibility.
Insurance coverage presents a separate issue.
A homeowners insurance policy may provide coverage for damage to the dwelling, subject to the policy's language, exclusions, and conditions. Automobile coverage may address vehicle damage, depending on the policy.
An insurer that pays a covered loss may also investigate whether it has subrogation rights against a responsible third party.
Consequently, a single electric vehicle fire could involve several parties, multiple insurance policies, and extensive technical investigation.
5. What Does “Self-Driving” Actually Mean?
The phrase self-driving car is frequently used to describe technologies that have very different capabilities.
Some systems merely assist a human driver. Others can perform substantially more of the driving task under specified conditions.
The Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) describes six levels of driving automation, ranging from Level 0 through Level 5.
Level
General description
0
No sustained driving automation
1
Driver assistance with steering or speed control
2
Combined steering and speed assistance; driver supervises
3
Conditional automation within defined conditions; driver must respond to takeover requests
4
High automation within a defined operational domain
5
Full automation under all driver-manageable roadway conditions
The legal distinction is critical.
A vehicle marketed with advanced driving assistance is not necessarily an autonomous vehicle.
In Level 2 systems, the human driver remains responsible for supervising the driving environment and performing the driving task as necessary.
A driver generally cannot avoid responsibility merely by claiming that a vehicle was operating in an automated assistance mode.
However, driver responsibility does not necessarily eliminate the possibility of manufacturer liability when defective technology contributes to a collision.
6. Who Is Liable When a Self-Driving Vehicle Causes an Accident?
Imagine a vehicle traveling along a Houston freeway while its driver-assistance system controls steering and speed.
The system fails to recognize stopped traffic and the vehicle strikes another automobile.
Several legal theories may become relevant.
Driver negligence
A driver may be negligent for failing to maintain a proper lookout, failing to intervene when reasonably necessary, or otherwise operating the vehicle without reasonable care.
The fact that the vehicle was using an automated assistance system does not automatically excuse the driver's conduct.
Manufacturer product liability
If a defective sensor, software system, or other component contributed to the collision, the manufacturer may face a product liability claim.
Potential allegations could involve defective design, defective manufacturing, or inadequate warnings and instructions.
The claimant must still establish the applicable legal elements, including causation.
Maintenance and repair negligence
A repair facility that improperly calibrates a sensor or damages a safety-critical component could potentially contribute to an accident.
Other responsible parties
Depending on the facts, additional parties may include component suppliers, fleet operators, commercial vehicle operators, or entities responsible for particular vehicle systems.
A collision involving advanced automation may therefore require a considerably more complex liability investigation than an ordinary rear-end accident.
7. Texas Law and Autonomous Vehicles
Texas has adopted a statutory framework governing automated motor vehicles.
Texas Transportation Code Chapter 545, Subchapter J addresses automated motor vehicle operation, including requirements concerning vehicle operation and compliance with applicable safety standards.
Texas law distinguishes automated driving systems from conventional driver-assistance features.
The statutory framework also addresses the responsibilities associated with automated vehicle operation, including situations in which the automated driving system is engaged.
Importantly, these provisions do not establish that every automobile equipped with advanced driver assistance may operate without human supervision.
Whether a vehicle qualifies as an automated motor vehicle, and whether its operation complies with Texas law, depends on the technology and applicable statutory requirements.
Further, statutory compliance does not necessarily resolve every potential civil liability question arising from an accident.
Product liability, negligence, insurance coverage, and federal regulatory requirements may remain relevant.
8. What If the Vehicle's Software Makes the Wrong Decision?
Modern vehicles increasingly depend on software to interpret information from cameras, radar, and other sensors.
These systems may identify surrounding vehicles, road markings, pedestrians, traffic signals, and potential hazards.
But software systems can fail.
For example, a vehicle might:
Not every mistaken response establishes a legally actionable defect.
A plaintiff alleging that defective software caused an accident must generally establish the existence of a legally recognized defect or other wrongful conduct and demonstrate the necessary causal relationship to the injury.
That may require expert testimony concerning the system's design, performance, and limitations.
Vehicle event data, software versions, sensor information, and records of updates may become important evidence.
9. Can a Software Update Create Legal Liability?
Electric vehicles and other modern automobiles may receive software updates remotely.
These updates can modify vehicle functionality without requiring the owner to visit a dealership.
This creates an interesting legal issue.
Suppose a manufacturer releases an update that changes how a vehicle responds to obstacles.
Following the update, several vehicles experience similar unexpected braking events.
If a collision occurs, investigators may examine whether the update introduced a defect, whether adequate testing was performed, and whether the manufacturer responded appropriately to known safety concerns.
The fact that a manufacturer can remotely modify a vehicle's behavior also raises questions about notice, warnings, corrective action, and preservation of evidence.
Liability is not automatic merely because a software update preceded an accident. Technical evidence establishing the relevant failure and causation would remain essential.
10. Can a Driver Blame the Manufacturer for an Accident?
Yes, under appropriate circumstances.
But a driver's assertion that the vehicle malfunctioned does not establish manufacturer liability.
Texas generally applies proportionate responsibility principles under Chapter 33 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code to covered claims.
A factfinder may be required to allocate responsibility among legally responsible parties.
For example, an accident could involve both a driver who failed to supervise an assistance system and a manufacturer whose defective system contributed to the collision.
The allocation of responsibility would depend on the evidence and applicable law.
Under § 33.001, a claimant generally cannot recover damages in a covered action if the claimant's percentage of responsibility exceeds 50%.
The precise application of Chapter 33 depends on the nature of the claims and parties involved.
11. Does Insurance Cover Self-Driving Accidents?
Insurance coverage depends on the policy, the circumstances, and the applicable law.
Ordinary automobile liability coverage may respond to covered accidents involving driver-assistance technology.
However, a collision involving an automated system can create disputes concerning who was operating the vehicle, which parties are legally responsible, and which insurance policies apply.
Commercial autonomous vehicle operations may present additional insurance and regulatory questions.
It is also important to distinguish first-party coverage from liability coverage.
Collision coverage generally concerns damage to the insured vehicle, subject to policy terms.
Liability coverage generally concerns covered claims involving injuries or property damage to others.
A claim against a manufacturer for a defective product is a separate matter from whether an automobile insurer owes coverage under a particular policy.
Consumers should not assume that the existence of sophisticated vehicle technology either eliminates or guarantees insurance coverage.
12. What Evidence Matters in an Electric Vehicle Lawsuit?
Electric vehicle litigation may involve evidence that does not ordinarily appear in conventional automobile cases.
Depending on the circumstances, relevant evidence may include:
Not all vehicles record the same information, and not all data will be accessible or retained.
Preserving the vehicle and relevant electronic evidence can be extremely important.
After a serious accident or battery fire, an owner should avoid unnecessary alteration, disposal, or destructive inspection of potentially relevant components.
Damaged high-voltage batteries may also remain hazardous. Inspection and storage should be coordinated with appropriately trained professionals.
13. What Damages May Be Available?
Depending on the legal claims and evidence, an injured party may seek compensation for legally recoverable damages.
These may include medical expenses, lost earnings, physical impairment, pain and suffering, and property damage.
In a fatal accident, eligible family members or estate representatives may have claims under applicable Texas wrongful death or survival statutes.
Some cases may also involve exemplary damages, but these require satisfaction of additional statutory requirements and are not available merely because an accident was severe.
Texas law also imposes various limitations and defenses that may affect recovery.
14. How Long Do You Have to Sue in Texas?
Many Texas personal injury and property damage claims are subject to a two-year statute of limitations under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 16.003.
However, the applicable deadline may depend on the particular claim, the parties, and other circumstances.
Product liability cases may also implicate the separate statutory repose provisions in § 16.012, including exceptions.
Claims involving governmental entities may have additional notice requirements and shorter deadlines.
Because electronic evidence can disappear and damaged vehicles may be repaired or destroyed, waiting until the limitations deadline approaches can create substantial practical problems.
15. The Future of Electric Vehicle Liability
Electric vehicles combine familiar legal principles with technologies that can make the investigation of an accident substantially more complicated.
A defective battery may raise traditional product liability questions, but proving the defect could require sophisticated engineering analysis.
A collision involving automated driving assistance may resemble an ordinary negligence case, but determining responsibility could require examining computer software, sensor systems, and driver interaction.
As automated driving technology develops, courts and lawmakers will continue confronting questions about the relationship between human supervision and machine control.
The fundamental legal questions, however, remain recognizable.
Was someone negligent? Was a product defective? Did the conduct or defect cause the injury? And what damages are legally recoverable?
New technology does not eliminate these questions.
It makes answering them more complicated.
Conclusion: Technology Changes, but Legal Responsibility Remains
Electric vehicles offer new capabilities, but their batteries, charging systems, software, and automated driving features also create distinctive legal risks.
When an electric vehicle causes injury or property damage, liability may rest with a negligent driver, a manufacturer, a repair facility, another responsible party, or some combination of them.
The most important distinction is between an accident involving an electric vehicle and an accident actually caused by defective electric vehicle technology.
Not every accident involving an electric vehicle is a product liability case.
And not every accident involving automated driving assistance is solely the driver's fault.
Determining responsibility requires examining the technology, the evidence, and the applicable law.
David C. Barsalou, Attorney at Law, PLLC, represents clients in civil litigation and other legal matters in Texas. Individuals facing disputes involving property damage, defective products, or other civil claims should seek legal advice based on their particular circumstances.
This article is provided for general educational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and regulations may change, and the outcome of any particular dispute depends on its facts.
At David C. Barsalou, Attorney at Law, PLLC, we help clients navigate business, family, tax, estate planning, and real estate matters ranging from document drafting to litigation with clarity and confidence. If you’d like guidance on your situation, schedule a consultation today. Call us at (713) 397-4678, email barsalou.law@gmail.com, or reach us through our Contact Page. We’re here to help you take the next step.